Flying blind: inside the decline of the EPA’s chemical-detection plane
Özet haber: Agency’s Aspect plane once was a key part of tracking toxic chemicals during disasters – why is it now often grounded?

Agency’s Aspect plane once was a key part of tracking toxic chemicals during disasters – why is it now often grounded?
When an ammonia leak outside a hotel in Weatherford, Oklahoma, injured 74 people last November, the federal government’s chemical-detection plane stayed on the ground. It also sat idle during a March fire at a Valero refinery in Port Arthur, Texas, and when blasts at a Toledo, Ohio, recycling plant killed two workers in August.
“Ten years ago, it would have gone to all of them,” said Mark Thomas, a former EPA official who managed the program for 18 years.
Known as Aspect, the plane was designed for emergencies involving toxic chemicals, oil spills and radiation. For two decades, it flew over disasters from Hurricane Katrina to the Deepwater Horizon oil spill.
But since early 2021, the single-engine Cessna has responded to just seven emergencies. Former Aspect scientists told the non-profit newsroom Floodlight that two of those missions – the 2023 East Palestine derailment and the 2025 Smitty’s Supply fire in Louisiana – were badly mismanaged.
At Smitty’s, the EPA declared the air safe, but a former Aspect scientist later found toxic chemicals the agency had missed. At East Palestine, the EPA’s inspector general is now auditing the agency’s response to the derailment, including the data behind its public assurances about air quality.
In June, the EPA inspector general found a more fundamental problem: the plane could no longer identify chemicals within minutes, as designed. Instead, the data had to be analyzed by hand, a process that takes about a week. That’s far too long to help anyone on the ground who’s deciding whether to evacuate.
The EPA said the plane’s chemical sensors are wearing out and expects replacements to be working by mid-2027.
But three people who helped build and run Aspect – Thomas, longtime Aspect scientist Robert Kroutil and former program manager Rick Turville - told Floodlight that the agency is fixing the wrong problem. They say the old sensors still work, but the EPA lost the expertise and initiative that made the program effective. They warn that replacement sensors could leave the agency even less capable of detecting hazardous chemicals.
“I fear that the public is at risk,” said Kroutil. “It’s such an important program, and they’ve allowed it to waste away to nothing.”
The EPA did not respond to Floodlight’s questions about the program’s decline, emergency responses or replacement sensors.
After the September 11 2001, attacks, the Department of Defense transferred its airborne chemical sensing program to the EPA for use in civilian emergencies.
Over its 25-year history, the plane has flown more than 80 emergency missions – an average of more than three a year.
But during an EPA reorganization in 2019, the agency told Aspect staff they had to relocate to Texas, where the plane was based, or face termination, an internal EPA memo shows. Thomas retired rather than uproot his family. Other key staff left. One accepted a demotion to stay in Kansas.



